We're on the April 13 San Juan to San Juan. To be honest the most they were planning on were sportcoats. We did the tux thing in the Med and in the Baltics, and even in Norway, but Alaska and Caribbean just don't seem like formal type destinations. Of course my only other Caribbean cruise was on the old Seabourne Sea Goddess which was CCC all the time. We have too many smokers in the group to do Oceania and we like balconies too much now to go with SeaDream. When you think about it, it's only an issue for men - we women can get away with most anything by adding accessories to basic black.