I wouldn't trust Consumer Reports for AV gear ... their ratings have been mocked on AV forums. And honestly, don't understand the criteria that they were rating the plasmas on when I was doing my research so I wouldn't necessarily believe what they say about LCD RPTV as well.

chip - you may also want to take a look at DLP technology. DLP RPTV is rated also quite highly - comparable to LCDs in many ways with better brightness. The Samsungs get raves from their owners. If you get a chance to see one at your local electronics/TV dealer, it might be worth your while. For something as big as 60-70 inch, if you can control the ambient light within the room, front projection LCD/DLP may also be worth a look as well - you'll definitely get more bang for the buck that way. Only problem is, don't know how practical it'll be for you - definitely more suited for MNF and movies than everyday watching.

BTW, on a completely aside note, plasma technology has advanced considerably. They're reporting 10+ years to half brightness which would not be apparent visually to most people. By then, you'd be looking at upgrading your TV again anyways ... :) Burn-in has essentially become a non-issue with proper set up and being reasonable about usage. I know people that have had their plasmas for 5+ years now with no decrease in quality of the picture. But as I said, this is completely aside the point since you won't find a 60 inch plasma at a reasonable price point.

Masaki