Yes, as far as Celebrity the nickel and diming $5.00 for a cappucino or a water to take ashore, $40.00 for a $7.99 bottle of wine, crowds everywhere for every thing, and the lack of quality food PLUS for a new ship we had some cleanliness issues with our room: The sheets kept coming off the bed, the shower was mildewed and tiles falling off and the vanity was stained. It was "icky"!
It ended up being about the same price or slightly cheaper than an RSSC cruise on promo with discounts and I'd rather spend a little more. There were also several families on board that were not the best mannered and that bothered us.
Tauck was wonderful in New England so we will do it again in Italy and I've heard nothing but the best about it.