I keep thinking the Voyager sounds better (I can dream!) I'm drawn to Phuket and Dubai. I think I need to google Easter Island and learn more. I'm disappointed that the Mariner doesn't go to Manila, but the Voyager does. Also disappointed that both cruises overnight in Tahiti instead of Bora Bora or Moorea. The Mariner goes to Bangkok and I can hear Tom now........HOW MUCH TIME DO I NEED TO SPEND IN BANGKOK (he lived and worked there for 6 months in the 90's and now we've been back 2 more times on the WCs).
Actually, both itineraries look awesome and have high points! Probably all wishful thinking anyway!