There are always a few people who are outstanding at their jobs and some that just dont do them correctly no matter what cruise line you are on. Sounds like Neville just hit a CD who was not doing his job that well. The most outstaning CD I have ever experienced was on Silversea. Within a few days he appeared to know every single passenger by name. Never ceased to amaze me.
Last time I was on Silversea and saw him he said he wanted to change to Radisson. I heard a few weeks ago he was with Crystal. Chalk one up for them.
The one thing I will note that I do see a little differently with RSSC and Silversea is the areas that Neville noticed and points out. RSSC does more token activity this type of thing and Silversea does less of this type of activity. Liars club for instance is popular on RSSC never seen that type of thing on Silversea. Not saying they dont have it I have just never seen it.
For many this makes no difference but for the people who enjoy the token and competitive activities this is something that would be missed. Also I do believe that the officers and the whole staff on RSSC has more of a "mingle and be friendly" mentality. That said some of the BEST and friendliest bartenders I have met on Silversea. So there are always exceptions to these types of generalizations.
These are minor things and many guests prefer the Silversea way. They dont like the contests and prefer to mingle with other guests rather than the officers or staff. I remember one past Silversea cruiser on a RSSC trip with me commented on these two issues as a negative for RSSC. She thought the trivia and games were "childish" and could not believe that passengers turned up for these events, and that the officers intruded on her privacy.
So as always different strokes for different folks.