We stayed on Guana Island and loved it. We've considered returning there.

Biras Creek was not quite our cup of tea, but that is where we had an exciting windsurfing lesson. (I was afraid I might sail right out to sea but the kind instructor came to my rescue!) Also, from Biras we were able to snorkel just off Necker Island which was certainly the closest we'd ever be able to get to that playground of the "Rich and Famous".

Although Young Island did not have such excellent snorkeling we loved our hillside room with a view; and after the occasion when a peacock came strolling into our bedroom suite I learned to keep the sliding screen door closed. We did three nights on a crewed sailboat to the Grenadines from Young Island - loved the snorkeling but my queezy stomach hated the sailing. The swells were 8 to 10 feet, sea bands did me no good. Since that experience I've learned to rely on Bonine tablets.

Have you been to Palm Island? We were considering that at one time. PSV is also quite tempting, but like Guana it is at the very top of what we could afford. (All those trips were prior to my husband taking an early retirement - now our trips are really a splurge for us.)